Top Stories

Fashion Faceoff: HALLE VS. NICOLE

Fashion Faceoff: HALLE VS. NICOLE

Halle Berry went grocery shopping in Malibu over Memorial Day weekend wearing a black Madison Marcus “Zest” Tunic, $299 at irisinger.com. The actress finished off her look with a white tote and a pair of simple metallic sandals.

Nicole Richie showed off some more leg in a shortened version of the same silk black day dress back in April, leaving a hair salon in Beverly Hills with boyfriend Joel Madden. The Simple Life star finished off her look with a black tote and a pair of metallic flats.

Who wears it best — HALLE BERRY or NICOLE RICHIE?

JJ Links Around The Web

  • Jennifer Garner's alleged stalker is arrested - PopEater
  • Heidi Klum and her kids go to the mall - PopSugar
  • The Jersey Shore gang rocks out - Celebuzz
  • Nicole Kidman doesn't care to talk Scientology - Dlisted
  • Celebs come out for Vanessa Hudgens' party - JustJaredJr
  • A CSI: Miami star is arrested - TheSuperficial
  • Penelope Cruz & Javier Bardem visit NYC - LaineyGossip
Rachel Worth/WENN

73 Comments

# 1

I love Halle Berry…but i think that nicole took this one.lol

# 2

For some reason when I see the picture I gravatate more torwards Nicole Richie, I don’t even notice Halle, it doesn’t mean that Halle looks bad,but some clothes work for some people and they don’t for others, definately I agree with BAMPZS,nicole takes this one, even though Halle is a millions times prettier and healthier looking

# 3

nicole all the way, she’s so thin i love it…halle looks fat, is she pregnant?

# 4
[Fug Face You] @ 05/28/2007 at 6:06 pm

Jared I feel like knuckling you down for this thread. Lmao

Halle of course.

# 5

I hate to admit this but Nicole on this one…………

# 6

For your information jam Halle looks healthy, not fat, the dress only looks better on Nicole because she had it cut to be that short, what a ****

# 7

Omg, Halle wears a 299 dollar dress to go grocery shopping??? Thats hot! She works the dress better, but Nicole’s body looks better then I have seen her (that was in April)looking for a while.

# 8
BradAngMadZShiPaxLove @ 05/28/2007 at 6:08 pm

Nicole.Nicole looks hot. I like her lots.Haley I like her too and she looks good but her dress is missing a little something.Maybe the length,hard one.

# 9

Halle Berry, fat? Some of you on here have a seriously messed up view of what a normal body is. Anorexic-looking is NOT normal!

Halle looks better, hands down!! She always looks good.

well Nicole of course.Haley still looks nice.

Haley is one hot mama but that dress is dull on her, Nick gives it some bang,punch,or whatever,,Nick wears it better.

Hell has frozen over… because I actually think that Nicole looks better in that dress than the epitome of beauty itself, Ms. Halle Berry.

Definitely Nicole. How can it be that she actually looks good in something? :) Anyway, this dress suits her to a “T”.

It looks best on Halle.

ok ,well... @ 05/28/2007 at 6:20 pm

I say Nicky. I like her shoes better,and the blonde hair makes the black colored dress stand out.Haley is very beautiful but her glasses distact.

hate to say it but I like Nicole’s better…I like short dresses

Nicole…the dress is waay to loose on Halle and only adds to the pregnancy rumors

I never would have thought that Halle Berry could actually look frumpy, but that dress does nothing for her.

Definitely Nicole. It also looks like Nicole has put on some weight. Thank God.

[Fug Face You] @ 05/28/2007 at 6:37 pm

People don’t actually think Halle’s fat, they just saying that because she’s black. On every ‘black’ thread its the same people saying the same ish.

I think Richee wears it better she has a youthful look about her where as my girl Haley pretty as she is looks dull neck up,maybe its the shades.

Both pretty @ 05/28/2007 at 6:45 pm

OMG HALEY HAS A DREAM BODY who woulnt want it.But Nicole looks good in that dress maybe its the blonde hair bringing out the black colored dress.Nicole wears it better.

Ms.Berry looks aged somehow.When we all know she looks nice.Nickole is youthful looking and she cracks me up so Nickole kicks it better.

sad to say…(for the anorexic problems) but nicole by far!

Is Haley angry?she luks it.Haley”s dress I think is made out of satin or silk and Nickies made out of velvet.These two are hard to choose from, Im a fan of both, mostly Nickie, shes closer to my age, but if I was being honest, Id say Nickie does justice to the dress.Haley has been luking rough in the face latley, but shes getting lots of affection and late nights with that young thing of hers, shes datin and shes no spring chicken, but she luks gorgess 99% of the time, get some rest Haley.

you did a little switcheroo… halle has the white tote, and nicole has the black one. dude i love this site, but maybe you should get a proofreader? i find typos and other little mistakes all the time.

Of course it’s Nicole Richie.
Sh’es thin and cool.
And Nicole’s legs look rly good..so does her hair..

NICOLE,SHE LOOKS FIERCE!Id kill to have those legs.Sorry Haley.

What is DOING with her???!!!

i love nicole
who could compete with her great sense of fashion?

No doubt. @ 05/28/2007 at 7:58 pm

Nicole!

jen a. fan @ 05/28/2007 at 8:03 pm

Jen would look better than both but since shes not in the contest ill go with nioole, haley is cute though she anit fat,but jen would wear it better than both cuz of her all over apperance.

Richee looks fabulous.thats all.Haley maybe heels with it next time.Nicole hands down.

i hate to say it too but nicole hands down

STUPID COMPARISON!! TWO DIFFERENT DRESSES. HAlle is wearing a loose tent dress for comfort… Nicole is wearing a top as a dress, closing fitting and probably over shorts. Her aim ? To get the guy holding her hand and any others in her vicinity focused on her legs and hot under the collar. Two totally different looks.

Who cares, Even though the answer is Nicole looks better, Joel & Nicole were married in November of 06′, how do I know? Let’s just say a few of us were there…BUT no one found out, not even any bloggers! HA Perez! Looza! Anyhoo, yes peeps, but they are now in the process of having it anulled. Check the facts, check every pic since that time, they each are wearing their wedding bands since November, look at the Simple Life promo pix…Nicole deliberately shows her ring, BUT, NOW Mr. Lionel Richie is working overtime to keep it hush hush…and get it anulled quickly, thank God there was a pre-nup. They were married in Lionel Richie’s living room November 6th, 2006…see Nicole never under estimate me girlfriend…check mate!

Nick’s rockin it.

MS.Berry makes that look like a house dress and the flip flops are to casual.Nicole makes it look more dressy so Nicole wears it the best.Short dresses are in.

Nicole takes this one. she looks so cute.

Halle looks better in fitted clothes

HALLE IS WITH THE WHITE TOTE & NICOLE WITH THE BLACK ONE, I THINK YOU GOT IT THE OTHER WAY AROUND

oh crap - Haley is going food shopping for crying out loud. That she thinks to wear this dress for a chore makes me chuckle. She doesn’t care. They both look great for their respective ages, situations and style. Halle is pregnant, fashion confident and older, Nicole is an anorexic child with a great sense of style. Why compare, just enjoy.

I LOVE them both I didnt know Haley was pregnant Congrats Nick does the dress better though,love her, but love Haley too GoGirls!!

Halle Looks A Little Frumpy. The Dress Just Doesn’t Look Right On Her. Nicole Took This One. :]

you all sound like complete ******* idiots for even trying to compare HALLE BERRY to NICOLE “****** SKIN N BONES” RICHIE…congrats. This site blows.

I’m surprised Nicole looks better.

caribbean queen @ 05/28/2007 at 10:37 pm

Nicole only looks better here because Halle must have put on some weight. Her arms aren’t as lean and her thighs are looking thicker than I have seen them in the past. Huh. Maybe Halle is in first stages of pregnancy, getting ready to “reveal” in a couple of months. Wouldn’t that be great!

luv nickie luv haley their both babes with different body types but nickie wears this black dress better but haley would be mighty fine in jeans shes so hot..luv em!!!

NICOLE wore it better.

Halle kinda looks fat in it.

aint this a blip @ 05/29/2007 at 12:26 am

Halle Berry looks pregnant.

nick is a pretty hot misses in the dress shoes are nice,haley it doesnt work as well,haley got a bad@ss body though but the dress fits nick better.

Halle. I don’t know what’s in the eyes of the rest of you.

nick has great style so nick.thats not the right dress for haley.

Croatian girl @ 05/29/2007 at 2:48 am

Halle!!!!! Halle!!!! Halle!!

Snarky Sharky @ 05/29/2007 at 3:24 am

Hmm… this dress is too much britney-ish despite its color. Fugly on both though Nicole is less fug in it.

Hate to say it but nicole wins hands down

JustAnotherNobody @ 05/29/2007 at 9:45 am

Oh my God, Nicole’s looking really nice here. Much healthier than just a few weeks ago.
I’d say she wears the dress better. Not that it looks bad on Halle either, but I think this is one of those dresses you need to be quite thin to look good in.
And I don’t mean that Halle’s fat or anything. She’s got just a bit shapelier figure than Nicole, that’s all.

why Halle why?!
of course Nicole is much better in this dress
i have noticed lately that Halle Berry improved a lot her style in clothes,hair and makeup,
but why did she do this mistake.
obviously by comparison that dress did not fit her properly…
i say she should have a word with her stylist

I agree with Liz, Nicole has great style and she definetly looks the best in this dress.

They both looks good but Nicole wears the dress better…

NICOLE FOR SURE!

Like both these women but Richie takes this one.

Nice dress but does nothing for Berry. Maybe in a different color?

reply to fuck face you @ 05/29/2007 at 2:47 pm

Both Halle and Nicole are metis (black and white for sure and maybe hispanic blood 4 nicole). They are METIS not only black or only white, so elevate the debate , stop thinking that we judge people on how “black” or “white” oe “banana” they are…….annoying really

Oh, I was hoping there was something new about Halle and her beautiful beau. Darn! I’m getting restless here. Halle, oh Halle… hmm. A few of you have mentioned it, but since she’s not saying it, I don’t want to get my hopes up and imagine that she could be pregnant. Her face looks different around her chin and cheeks.

Nicole simply because on halle it looks like a sack. There’s no definition in her body. it’s one long straight potato sack. Nicole spices it up a bit because she shows off her legs.

SweetHoneybee @ 05/29/2007 at 9:56 pm

HALLE. That woman’s name is H-A-L-L-E. Haley would be Hillary Duff’s older sister.

i love nicole, but who cares…
JOEEEEEEEEEEL !!!

lizwrites2007 @ 05/31/2007 at 12:36 am

Neither one looks superb in the dress. Nicole does look good compared to what she’s looked like in the past. Halle looks okay (no offense).

Lizzie etal don’t even start with the pregnancy rumors–if Halle was pregnant every time the rumors have been flying over the last few years, she’d have more children than the Von Trapp Family or Josephine Baker (no offense Halle). I really do think we will really know it when she actually is.

There’s wrong with wishful thinking or wishing her the very best, but some of the pictures on the internet with the stalkerrazzis going nuts every time she’s wearing baggy clothes, etc. or the pix of she and her mother shopping last week (followed by other pix of her wearing something skin tight–sorry no baby bump) are deplorable and go beyond the scope of Halle being a celebrity or her past comments of having a family.

Leave the woman alone. I am sure she’ll let us know really.

Where is Halle Berry? I have not seen any photos of her out and about in a while…And it has been even longer since I have seen a photo of her and her boyfriend together…

i think nicole richie is a little prettier, but over all the whole outfit just looks better on halle. She chose a better bag and better shoes to go with it, and it looks good on her without her having to show off her legs.

Least Halle wore hers with a bit of dignity so I’m going with her…

Comment and Share!








You have of 5,000 characters left.