OlderFri, 27 July 2007 at 1:20 pm
Fashion Faceoff: Juicy Couture Dress
Ashley Tisdale goes green in Juicy Couture dress in delicate floral lace at the 2007 ABC All-Star Party in Beverly Hills on Thursday. The High School Musical actress finished off her look with a Juicy pair of matching bow-trimmed sandals and Louis Vuitton Monogram Multicolore Ursula handbag in black.
Mischa Barton wore the same Juicy dress as she strolled NYC’s Soho last month. The former O.C. star finished off her look with a mesh fedora hat, Grecian-style sandals and a Chanel handbag.
Who wore it best — ASHLEY TISDALE or MISCHA BARTON?
Share This Post:
Photos: Frazer Harrison/Getty, Axelle/Bauer-Griffin, A. Macpherson/Ed Isabella/Splash News Online
Posted to: Ashley Tisdale, Fashion Faceoff, Mischa Barton
Related posts:
Posted to: Ashley Tisdale, Fashion Faceoff, Mischa Barton
Related posts:
84 Comments
Actually I don’t like the dress on either of them-it makes them look pregnant. Good thing Jennifer Garner didn’t wear it!~
Mischa, of course! She has class, Ashley doesnt. I hate that Louis Vuitton bag !
Ashley Tisdale definitely. That fedora hat just doesn’t work.
Of course Mischa!! Mischa is gorgeous!
For all the Sienna hater’s out there. This dress would also look FABULOUS on Sienna Miller! Sienna’s got the best looking legs!
I think Ashley does the dress more justice.
Mischa. Ashley looks like a man in drag.
the handbag doesn’t match with the dress.
ashley, because mischa’s hat just ruins it
so. i like the dress on both of them
and i like ashley tisdale
but her face is whats wrong with the outfit, and that black LV.
but i love the necklace and shoes =]
but when it comes to Ash vs. Mischa.
i say Mischa hands down
From waist up, Mischa looks better. From waist down, Ashley looks better.
Mischa has weird-looking legs.
Definitely Ashley. Mischa makes me gag.
Did you guys hear about Nicole’s jail time? You can vote about it on http://www.hollywoodheathens.com
Ashley wears it much better!
Definitely Mischa, on ashley, the bag SCREAMS trying to hard, i.e (new money) plus that bag was so 4 years ago. on mischa the chanel chain bag fits perfectly, plus the hat add’s a bit of spunk.
def ashley. and shoes r supa cute
I don’t like Mischa but she does look way better in this dress
IMHO, Mischa looks awful. Her face is demented and her legs look disproportionately big…
Ashley’s not so cute in the face either (looks like Hayley (sp?) Duff), but the dress works better on her small frame and with her complexion (fake tan or not).
Mischa!! Ashley looks kinda gay. And her purse killed it!!
I’d say Mischa . Ashley looks really weird with that dress green with a Fake tan looks ugly.
ASHLEY, Mischa looks like a Plain Jane Hippie…so blah
Eww Mischa. I’m happy we haven’t been seeing pictures lately of that overexposed starlet.
Ashley Tisdale Wore the dress Way better then Mischa.Because I ♥ Ashley Tisdale’s Bag and shoes so I say Ashley!Ashley Is a way better Rolemodel to!
Mischa!
Who is this Ashley Tinsdale? Every time I turn around there’s a new little girl being photographed.
Can’t stand ‘****-on’ but she even looks better than the ugmo weave extension girl.
Ashley tisdale….she looked better in this dress…and sweet….but the dress of Vanessa hudgens is sooo nice ….she look beautiful!!!!
MISCHA OFCOURSE!
They both look really good in it. But Mischa looks a little bit better!
Ashey Tisdale:):)
the dress fits mishca better. she doesnt look like a complete fruitcake in it!
Are you kidding me? The LV bag clashes with the outfit. Mischa hands down.
Mischa. Not loving the dress on Ashley and the bag just ruins the outfit.
mischa, for sure she looks so casual and hip whereas ashley looks like an overtanned girl. she tries too hard. mischa ftw
Ashley, Hands-down
ASHLEY TISDALE by far! I’m not sure when it happened, but Ashley has turned out to be a gorgeous girl. I’d kill for those legs! Her sandals are sexy, too - I think Mischa looks kind of silly.
I can’t get excited about either one.
What’s worse is thinking about how much those ugly dresses must have cost.
Depressing.
Ashley. Mischa looks ridiculous. For a skinny girl, Mischa sure has some flabby out-of-shape legs. She’s trying way to hard with the fedora, and on her the dress looks like a giant green tent. Ashley is on the tacky with that annoying LV bag but otherwise she at least looks pretty good
Of cpurse Ashley Tisdale!!
Look at her, she is so beautiful!
She is the best, and her bag is so cute =)
ASHLEY YOU ROCK!
Misha for sure!
Ashely with the bad nose job looks like a tacky NJ socialite. Mischa rocks the whole look cus she looks like she’s not trying so hard to look good.
psh ashley so wore it better
mischa makes the whole thing look grungy and dirty.
ashley makes it look fresh.
so ashley
ashley looks wayyy better.i love the dress.nd her bag is soo cuteee.i love her outfit.nd those shoes r so cute.ashley all the wayyy.
mischa even tho i hate her. i didnt realize ashley had such big feet.
Mischaa!!!
Deffinately Ashley.
OMG! a ash tava muito perfeita
Ashley rocks the frock
Ashley defiantly looks better. I love her bag.
And besides, Ashley is a bigger star then Mischa. Does anyone even consider Mischa part of Hollywood, because last time I checked, it’s Ashley on TV and in the Magazines. Not Mischa.
I lovvee Ashley Tisdale! But I say they both look good in it. Ashley wears it to sport of a girly,vintage type of look and Mischa does it to make a vintage,going shopping look!
mischa barton
ASHLEY. i hate mischa’s hat, it doesn’t work w/ the dress.
ashleyy.she looks better.
Ashley, obviously. Mischa has like fat legs. It just doesn’t go.
mischa
ashley, definitely, even if i dont like her. mischa’s hair and her legs are ew- her fashion style is soo overrated!
ASHLEY:
Dress - Too wide
Accessories:
LV bag - looks stupid next to that dress, her arm on her bag makes it appear that she is trying to show of the bag
Shoes - another green color than the dress + the ribbons looks ridiculous next to the LV bag
Neckless - disturbing next to all the other elements
White nails - matches the ugly looking ribbons on her shoes
Pout - makes her look like a brat
Conclusion: Too many disturbing elements
-*-*-*-
MISCA:
Dress - A bit too long - making her legs looks very short, but besides that it’s good for her figure
Accessories:
Handbag - Neutral, doesn’t mess up the outfit
Shoes - matches her ring, likes the orange-red details
Hat - cool
Black nails - matches the hat
Pout - looks a bit sophisticated
Conclusion: A bit too long, but looks way better on MISCHA
does anyone know where ashley got her sandals?
They don’t seem to be wearing the same dress to me. I think Mischa’s looks like the original style, elegent thought I wouldn’t wear it myself. The other seems to be totally distorded and almost cheap-looking.
Ashley definately.
The sandals that Ashley is wearing is by Juicy Couture but the sandal is no longer available in that color.
I will say Mischa just because i am so over this LV purse.
thanks pink diva! is there any way i could get these sandals? i live in vegas.
At the Juicy Couture store in Vegas. There number is 702-365-5600.
MISCHA! Ashley looks weird,the bag ruins it.
ashley.i love her outfit
both wear the dress very nice but over all i have to say ashley wears it beter i mean yea bad clashes but you can put a bad down lol hide it in a corner and i dnt no why some people are diss’n the LV bag i love them lol so yea i think ashley wears it beter the hat just totaly ruins that dress and the gold chain with ashley just makes it even more gawjuss lol
err, the dress isn’t all that great but I mean if Mischa was wearing it just to go outside for a cup of coffee or something I could handle it, but erm, Ashley, what are you doing? An event and she’s wearing that sweater thing.. emm ok,, at least you could match a little k?
Ashley, 100%
Claro que é na maravilhosa diva Tisdale!
MEESH!
ASHLEY!
Mischa’s hat is ugly and does not match and Ashley fills it out better and she has a wayy better body i mean HELLO look at mischa’s legs gross!
ashley !!!
the hat ruins it for mischa, and she doesnt have the figure/skin colour to wear it.
at first look, i thought mischa was one of those russian models, the ones that no one knows why they are models. (sorry if that confused you, but i didnt know how else to put it)
ill admit that the LV bag does clash, but without the bag, it looks fab.
the necklace and the shoes match perfectly, and FYI, she doesnt do fake tan. thats real..
i say ashley hands down.
i really think that Misha Barton and Ashley Tisdale r really great actors and look hot in this dress and i am there biggest and hugest fan of Misha Barton and Ashley Tisdale
I just really love ‘em
I think Ashley Tisdale looks way better than Mischa Barton.Ashley is also way better looking.Its just that they put up an ugly pic of her:D
ASHLEY TISDALE ROX
ashley tisdale looks toally better in it!
Ashley by far
Ash looks so georgeous & sweet. Misha too!
But I like Ashley wearing that dress :) The LV is not ok with the dress but well..
Ashley of course
Ashley always looks awesome. The bag didn’t go well with it, but I still think she pulled it off more, sorry Mischa.
ashley looks better. it doenst matter if her handbag doesnt match. as long as it’s cute. and it is.
Ashley Deffinatly!
ashley tisdale definetly! :D
she is absolutely stunning! she looks gorgeous in that dress! :D
love here
ashley is better
OF COURSE Misha !!!!
she knows real fashion
Comment and Share!
E-mail to a Friend or share on Facebook, Twitter, MySpace and more!