Top Stories

Fashion Faceoff: Jay Godfrey Dress

Fashion Faceoff: Jay Godfrey Dress

Zoë Saldaña hit the Beverly Hills InStyle summer soiree in a scarlett red Jay Godfrey dress on Thursday. The 29-year-old actress finished off her look with a pair of matching red strappy sandals.

Vanessa Hudgens showed off a cream-colored version of the frock at a TCA event in Los Angeles last month. The High School Musical 2 star finished off her look with snakeskin pointy pumps.

Who wore it best — ZOE SALDANA or VANESSA HUDGENS?

JJ Links Around The Web

Miguel Villagran/Getty

147 Comments

# 1
stillthereforme @ 08/17/2007 at 1:13 pm

vanessa!!!!!

# 2

V-A-N-E-S-S-A H-U-D-G-E-N-S OF COURSE!!!

# 3

Vanessa!

# 4
gabriella @ 08/17/2007 at 1:16 pm

Vanessa of course..!
She looks gorgeous.
first comment .!=)

# 5
gabriella @ 08/17/2007 at 1:17 pm

not first comment then..

# 6

They both look hot to me. That dress is smoking by the way…

http://www.hiddenonlinedeals.blogspot.com

# 7

Vanessa is sooo beautiful!

# 8

Any doubt?!

VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV

Vanessa Anne Hudges, obviously haha

Vanessa by far…Zoe looks quite frail lately

Vanessa ofcorz

Vanessa, definitely.
Zoe looks too thin.

Zoë Saldaña

they both look good but vanessa.

VANESSA ROCKS THIS DRESS

vanessa! =]
SHE’S SOOO GORGEOUSSS!

Vanessa, of course! :)

VANESSA HUDGENS!!!!!!!!
VANESSA HUDGENS!!!!!!!!
VANESSA HUDGENS!!!!!!!!
VANESSA HUDGENS!!!!!!!!
VANESSA HUDGENS!!!!!!!!
of course!!

Vanessa FTW! ^_^

[~Famous~] @ 08/17/2007 at 1:49 pm

Zoë of course, she’s a women.

definitely vanessa…she’s look so pretty =]

VANESSA ANNE HUDGENS!!!!!!!

VAN
BABY V
NESSA
VAN
VANNY!!!

SO CUTE

VANESSA HUDGENS!!!

Baby V all day

the other girl looks so good!!
but i cant stop looking at vanessa, she’s like an angel that you can get addicted to LOL*

though I WISH she couldve had the dress tighter, cuz the girl has the perfect hour glass figure too!

Vanessa by far wore it best.

Vanessa of course ♥
She looks gorgeous

vanessa hands down

vanessa she pulls this dress of soooo much better

vanessa because she pulls it of better

posh mini me @ 08/17/2007 at 2:57 pm

They both look great but I like Vanessa’s look better.

VANESSA ! ♥

she is just adorable

Vanessa..something looks odd with the other girl

vanessa. DUH!

patricia night @ 08/17/2007 at 3:19 pm

Zoe Saldana
She looks great

vanessa hudgens shes gorgeous!! ♥

VANESSA, Zoe always looks like a drug addict to me.

vanessa hands down.

They both look good, but Vanessa fills it out a little more.

BABY V!!

Vanessa Hudgens! Shes freakin’ dating Zacster so shes hotter than that crap whos wearing that freakin’ red dress!!!

Vanessa!!
thats like no competition
she wore it best and looks
10 times better

randomgirl1111 @ 08/17/2007 at 4:11 pm

vanessa is to fat for this dress
ZOE!

vanessssa!

This is a tough one Jared. Who do you think I’ll pick? LOL btw she wore that dress during the ABC Upfronts not TCA.

lol yea i ‘wonder’ Chay.

i love Zoë && she’s rockin that dress.

but you know i have to give it up for my girl V!
the whole ensemble is just tres magnifique! c’est tres, tres jolie!
besides the fact that she was rockin that Jay Godfrey dress first lol

snaps to V. =P

vanessa for sure

definitely vanessa !

N0 DuH VANESSA L0L
SHE’S WAAAY G0RGE0US!!!!!!!!!!
L0VE HER!!!

Zoë Saldaña. It actually was one of the v’s ugliest outfits.

i like both girls. but i have to say vanessa!

vanessa looks the best by the way after vanessa wore it like two other ppl wore it but v looked the best

vanessa of course
she rocked it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

VANESSAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

vanessa of course no doubt about that
she looks goegous as always

Vanessa Hudgens!!! all the wayy!!!!!!!!!!

VANESSA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1 ALLLLLLLLLLLL THEEEE WAYYYYYYYYY SHE IS SOOOO GORGEOUSSS THE OTHER GIRL WAYY WAYY WAYY TOO THIN!!!

VANESSA
VANESSA
VANESSA!
I LOVE HEER

I LOVE THEM BOTH IN THEM. THEY BOTH LOOK GOOD IN THE DRESSES.

Vanessa Hudgens all the way!i mean, its umcomparable!!

duh. they both look great. but zoe looks like a supermodel, that’s hot.

duuh vanessa!

vanessa all the way

Definitely Vanessa!

Vanessa Hudgens, obviously.

OMG!
dude Vanny for sure
she look everything in this dress

#baby V

Zoe Zoe Zoe.

Perfect in red. She is so pretty.

The ballerina of course. Zoe is a SWAN, elegant, chic and artistically gifted. Vanessa is cute but she’s got the dorky pose about her and the dress shows her thighs, not cute. she’s only a kid though. she’ll learn

It both fit them but, I think Vanessa gives a lil’ more curve to the dress…

Vanessa!!!!!

helloogoodbye @ 08/18/2007 at 6:03 am

Obviously vanessa! She always looks stunnin!

vanessa hudgens!!!

Vanessa, of course.

VANESSA ALL THE WAY

BABY V the other girl dress is too red.Plus she’s so frail.

zoe looks better to me way more better.

Sofy García @ 08/18/2007 at 2:51 pm

I think Vanessa Hudgens’s dress is more beutiful… i liked the beige color!….

Vanessa Hudgens looks more beutiful than Zoe…

V Rocks!

Vanessa dude! *-* of course!
she’s perfect in this dress, and she also bought the dress firts than the other dudette, we know this x)
xoxo :*

vanessa hudgens! definatly. she’s gorgeous. to all the ******* haters, go **** off somewhere else

Jessica (Brazil) @ 08/18/2007 at 7:48 pm

VANESSA ! SHE ROCKS 4EVER 8D
xoxo :*

Vanessa, of curse ! I love her, it’s so cute! ♥

of course vanessa!

OMG definitely baby V!!!! she’s hot stuff:P

Vanessa of course!

VANESSA HUDGENS

Vanessa!!!!!! ofcurzeee..
vanessa
vanessa
vanessa she’s georgeous!!
vanessa….
vanessa

vanessa!!!
VANESSA!!!

Of course my Baby V!

It’s totally gottaa be VANESSA HUDGENS!!
like OMG!! she wore it sooooo BEAUTIFULLY!!

VANESSA OF COURSE
U CANT ASK
IS OBVIOUS VANESSA LOOKS BETTER

i think both look hot.

i love how the red colour stands out so vibrantly from zoe’s skin. but i also love the ‘innocent angel’ look on vanessa. i also like the tight waist on zoe, it definitely doesn’t look as good loose like vanessa’s.

its true that if you look at those photos, you won’t be able to stop looking at vanessa. she’s totally glowing in that dress! but still, that dress somehow fits zoe better so i choose zoe in the end.

zoe is hottest she is like the beuty made person.
no doubt… zoe is the best.

Vanessa Hudgens all the way!!! She and I have the same name btw… not making it up… I think she has the best style, and knows how to dress… the whole outfit is totally awesome!!! Vanessa Hudgens is best dressed! Go Zanessa!!!

vanessa the other girl looks to chiseled

ZOE, OF COURSE!!!

Good choice of color for their skin tones!

Zoë Saldaña looks the best.
I don’t like the shoes vanessa picked for that dress.

vanessa the other chick is too matchy and v’s shoes rock!!!! and the color looks great on her

Vanessa… the other dress is an ugly color, and its weird. Plus, the other girl is too skinny and the dress is too tight on her.

of course 98% of ya’ll would say vanessa…
both of them rocked it in their own way!! they look gorgeous!

Vanessa hands down

VANESSAbt i do like the dress beter in the colour red lol

VANESSA!!!!

BY FAR!

vanessa. :]
always.

vanessa is hot but this dress is damn amazing looks great on both

Alyssa Burgess @ 08/26/2007 at 5:20 pm

Vanessa Hudgens 100%

Christine @ 09/13/2007 at 3:44 pm

Vanessa Hudgens of course

of course…vanessa!!!!!!!!!!!!

vanessa anne hudgens…fabulous

..::>> DAMN VANESSA IS FINE SHE LOOKS WAY BETTER

jocepinky @ 09/14/2007 at 6:15 pm

vanessa
zoe it toooooooo skinny
get some weight zoe!!!

VANESSA HUDGENS
DUH!!

VANESSA!!!!!!!!!

Nessa looks so good, much better than the other chick. the color suits her warm skin tone and her full, but not fat figure. she’s absolutely glowing and radiantly gorgeous. I LOVE IT!!!

to be honest……..Vanessa!

Marcella. @ 09/26/2007 at 5:02 pm

Vanessa Hudgens = )

vanessa of cOurse.!!

VANESSA!!!!!!! all the way!!!!!

Vanessa baby!

Vanessa has a better body for it.

of course V! She’s THE BEST!!!! I LOVE YOU BABY V!

VANESSA ANNE HUDGENS OF COURSE I’M HER BIGGEST FAN AND SHE ROCKS ALL THE TIME

i think the other girl looks okay but vanessa wore it best

Vanessa Hudgens of course. That other woman’s TOO skiinyy.. =]

Vanessa
She Rocks
And Shes A Close Friend
So Yeah !!!

Ox

sorry bt that zoe chicks body is rokin this dress v is a little i dunno shrt?

Vanessa of course, she’s the best :)

Vanessa, of course!
Baby V rocks!

Vanessa! of course!!!

This isn’t even the same dress, so it has a completely different look. However, I think I prefer Zoe’s version because it is more flattering and less bulky and fat looking. It’s just that she was caught at a weird pose, so it looks awkward.

I love zashnessa Hudgens @ 05/04/2008 at 9:05 am

vanessa Hudgens looks better she is so beautiful and the dress are beautiful too.

OUTOFTHISWORLD_X3 @ 07/13/2008 at 8:13 pm

Vanessa Hudgens :]

vanessa of course!!!!!…duh!!!

Vanessa!!!
of courze!
zoe looks
too thin…..

♥♥♥Ja§mInε♥♥

V
A
N
E
S
S
A

H
U
D
G
E
N
S

FOREVER

Comment and Share!








You have of 5,000 characters left.