Top Stories

Fashion Faceoff: Azzedine Alaia Dress

Fashion Faceoff: Azzedine Alaia Dress

Naomi Campbell sashayed her way into the Hermes fashion show during the Paris Fashion Week on Saturday in a taupe sleeved Azzedine Alaia dress. The cell-phone-tossing supermodel finished off her look with black holey boots.

Mariah Carey’s see-through skirt on her black version of the dress revealed a bit more undergarment in NYC back in June. The superstar singer completed her look with a blingin’ bracelet and a pair of YSL Tribute pumps in matching black patent.

Victoria Beckham donned a beige version of the dress during her interview with The Today Show also back in June. Posh finished off her look with a pair of matching beige Christian Louboutin pumps and over-sized shades.

Who wore it best — NAOMI CAMPBELL, MARIAH CAREY or VICTORIA BECKHAM?

Campbell-azzedine naomi campbell azzedine alaia dress 01
Campbell-azzedine naomi campbell azzedine alaia dress 02
Campbell-azzedine naomi campbell azzedine alaia dress 03
Campbell-azzedine naomi campbell azzedine alaia dress 04
Campbell-azzedine naomi campbell azzedine alaia dress 05
Campbell-azzedine naomi campbell azzedine alaia dress 06
Campbell-azzedine naomi campbell azzedine alaia dress 07
Campbell-azzedine naomi campbell azzedine alaia dress 08
Campbell-azzedine naomi campbell azzedine alaia dress 09
Campbell-azzedine naomi campbell azzedine alaia dress 10

JJ Links Around The Web

  • ANTM's Miss J is the co-father of a 7-year-old boy - Dlisted
  • Nicole Richie and Harlow grab coffee - PopSugar
  • Tracy Morgan fans didn't like his strong language - PopEater
  • Twilight tops People's Choice nominations - JustJaredJr
  • Britney Spears is a bikini babe - TheSuperficial
  • Holly Madison's not a Girls Next Door fan - Celebuzz
  • Emily Blunt and John Krasinski are adorable together - LaineyGossip
Photo: Amy Sussman/Getty

151 Comments

# 1
DVBeckham @ 10/07/2007 at 5:07 pm

Victoria DUHH!!!

# 2

victoria ftw.

# 3

victoria definitely

# 4

victoria all da way!

# 6

mariahhhh of course man!
she looks so hot in that pic!!

# 7

Victoria, only because Mariah’s see-thru.

Naomi’s been rocking Victoria’s glasses everywhere lately.

# 8

Victoria…definitely.

# 9

victoria!

Mariah wore it best. Victoria is just a stick with two boobs, how can she wear something better?

Victoria.. the dress looks better on a smaller frame.

Victoria. She looks amazing.

Victoria Beckham and I don’t even like Posh

Yeah…definitely Victoria.

MARIAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Victoria, is wayyyyyyyyyyyyy to skinny! She needs to eat a hamburger, or two!

Naomi Campbell, NO! She is Hideous!

MARIAH, WINS! :P

posh mini me @ 10/07/2007 at 5:33 pm

posh..of course :)

blueangel @ 10/07/2007 at 5:38 pm

Victoria looks good in almost anything, including this dress. Naomi is second. Mariah needs to lose weight before she will ever look good in something like this.

justmeagain @ 10/07/2007 at 5:38 pm

NAOMI all the way!!!

definitely victoria. posh rocked the dress…:)

WilliamsRockz @ 10/07/2007 at 5:55 pm

VICTORIA!!! Mariah looks fat and Naomi, as always, ugly!

Even though I am a fan of all three ladies.

Victoria rules this contest without a doubt.

Gabi Frones @ 10/07/2007 at 6:02 pm

Victoria, just amazing!

VICTORIA!

Victoria!Dress looks good on her because she is so tiny.

I’m going to go with the supermodel. Victoria is the same shade as her dress! Mariah just looks like a stuffed sausage with everything she wears!

Just me... @ 10/07/2007 at 6:07 pm

The robot wore it best… :D

um Victoria all the way!!!

Naomi needs to pay someone to do her hair properly! She look like an ugly *****!!

uh oh, what we have here are a bunch of anorexic, toothbrush craming down your throats people!

Mariah, looks lovely!She has the body of a sister! Her body is one fine Wonderland!

Posh, is so skinny. She almost looks rubbery! Now, I know why that hunk of a man that she has cheated on her, Her bones was probably poking him in his inner thighs! ewwwwww :(

Naomi, feet are so UGLY! They look like she walked on HOT COALS! GROSS!

Victoria, of course. I mean she might be skinny but you got too admit, the dress looks great.

Victoria, of course. I mean she might be skinny but you got too admit, the dress looks great.

victoria! doy@!

anonymous @ 10/07/2007 at 6:58 pm

VICTORIA!!!

Fug Face Jolie @ 10/07/2007 at 7:07 pm

its unanimous, david’s beckhams wife wins.

Definitely Victoria - the dress really complements her slender, tiny figure. Mariah’s breasts look like they’re six seconds from bursting out of her dress.

TEAM MARIAH

TEAM MARIAH

TEAM MARIAH

TEAM MARIAH

TEAM MARIAH

TEAM MARIAH

TEAM MARIAH

TEAM MARIAH :p

Victoria. Well its obvious….Look at her!

I prefer the dress in black but Alien Beckam wore it better than the two others. I like Carey`s shoes tough.

I think Victoria wears it best
Shes just so feminine and cute.
Pure adorableness. Heh

Victoria!!!!

Victoria!!!

Naomi is wearing Victoria’s sunglasses lately

Hate to say it, but Victoria has em thoroughly beat. ^_^

From the block @ 10/07/2007 at 9:00 pm

I dont like victoria but she OWNS that outfit.

Victoria!!

VICTORIA BECKHAM

ACTUALLY THIS IS ONE OF THE VERY FEW TIMES POSH SEEMS TO BE WEARING CLOTHING THAT DOES NOT MAKE HER LOOK LIKE A HOOKER AND HER DRESS IS DEFINTELY THE BEST OUT OF ALL THREE. POSH HAS TO HIDE HER UGLY FACE BEHIND THOSE BIG GLASSES.

POSH IS AS UGLY AS MARIAH CAREY.

v beck so def. usually im not a fan, but she looks the hotest for sure!

Ha! Do we even need to say?
Posh all the way! =)

POSH SPICE!!!!!
VB looks great than Naomy & Mariah.

VICTORIA! HANDS DOWN!

celery gloss @ 10/07/2007 at 11:39 pm

victoria! i forgot how cute her hair looks shorter.

Posh.
best colour and she’s skinny at least.

Posh wore it best!

i hate her , but she look way better than the others

victoria 100%

she is skinny but better than beaing fat like mariah

Mariah, of course! She was on point! Why to be so skinny like Victoria? OMG, it’s weird! Just the color is more beautiful, but I still prefer Mariah and her classic black!
Naomi? well, the 3rd for that boots!

Mariah by far. Victoria looks too skinny, naomi’s hair style in those pics arent the business

and why are you guys calling MC fat?? o.0
loook her arms, her legs, her body, she wasn’t fat!!!

francis archt1 @ 10/08/2007 at 2:31 am

mariah wins. nice pose. sexy with clevage. dress looks expensive among the 3.

victorias pose is childlike
naomis hair is messy and she looks old in that pic.

francis archt1 @ 10/08/2007 at 2:34 am

mariah wins. nice pose. sexy with cleavage. the dress looks more expensive among the 3.

victorias pose is childlike ..not her age.
naomis hair is messy. looks old.

MARIAH !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Is this seriously a question. Mariah, obviously.

Mariah. That dress with the shoes looks amazing. And since when have “curves” become “fat”?

Mimi looks amazing here. Posh is cute too with the hair, but I like the black version better.

Mariah! She looks gorgeous and her body is a million times better than posh’s.

Mariah Carey!!!

she’s so hot!!! LUVIN her till Death!!!

GO MIMI!!! GO!!!

Mariah. She’s got those curves, man. Her body is the gift that just KEEPS on GIVING. Posh and Naomi are sexy ladies too though. They all look good, but Mariah’s curves totally own this outfit.

i hate all of them!
if vanessa hudgens was ther id soo pick her!
btw im a boy and i want to sex vanessa hudgens.

victoria. she looks good in anything to be honest. also, that beige colour is the best.

mariah looks awesome init, posh just looks skinny an gross!

Mariah
Mariah
Mariah

Of course MARIAH! She wore it the best!

Mariah wins of course!!!

erwin januari indonesia @ 10/08/2007 at 5:52 am

Mariah is better all the way

Me Myself and i @ 10/08/2007 at 6:00 am

MARIAH!! Hands down

Mariah, of course! She lost so much weight recently.

definitely Mariah. shes got the right curves in the right places.

mariah 4 sure

I think mariah wins this one:)

shut upppp!!!!!!!!!!Mariah rules,she’s the queen of dresses and she can wear anything,victoria is so0o0o00o0o0o0o0o thin:S
naomi is ok

Posh, OF COURSE!!

Euan johnson @ 10/08/2007 at 9:16 am

of course Mariah wins!!!!!!!!!

MARIAH HANDS DOWN LOOKS BETTER…..MARIAH IS A SISTA AND THATS HOW A SISTER SHOULD LOOK….WHITE GIRLS HAVE NEVER HAD A SHAPE….EAT SOME FOOD VICTORIA!

Mariah's the best @ 10/08/2007 at 10:26 am

VICTORIA is UGLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

MARIAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

MARIAH you ROCK we LOVE you you’re the BEST!!!!!!!!!!

This dress is BUTT UGLY, but Mariah wears it best. Can’t believe that Posh and Naomi are considered style icons.

Mariah looks the best. She’s hott.

Mariah…she looks the best here. Mariah is always hott.

Victoria…definitely.

Mariah is a fat whoreeeeeeeeee.

real women have curves @ 10/08/2007 at 10:56 am

Mariah looks the best in the dress because she fills it out with curves and body! the other two shop at baby gap and look anorexic which is NOT sexy to me

Mariah, of course.I don’t like Victoria’s emaciated figure.

Mariah off course shes so beautiful.

Mariah of course hands down! Even though the dress is see through, she still looks good in it. The other ladies look boney, mariah on the other hand has that nice shape along with those sexy legs and is just perfect.

victoria definitely

Naomi! She’s too cool for school.
Not like posh trying OH SO HARD, dullard

victoria, hands down !!

VICTORIA! Definitely, no contest, she is a FASHION ICON and the only normal one here!

naomi is just ugly all the time so she is def. out. victoria does have a smaller frame than mariah so it looks good on her but this kind of dress needs to be worn by someone with curves and a hot body and that def means MARIAH WINS!

Mariah looks better. She is really beautiful, even though she has not got the best body

mariah wore it the best….naomi came in 2nd and victoria looks soo weird in it.

Mariah Carey wins by far! Beckham literally blends into her dress. A black dress/shoes would have given her a better chance. And Campbell turned the dress from couture to grunge with her goth boots and bad weave.

they all look stupid

Mariah looks fabulous..

MARIAH ALL THE WAY!!!!!

Mariah as always ruins a great dress…it’s too tight and of course it’s see through. This woman really needs to begin dressing for her age…or get in grandiose shape.

Mariah any day !!! HOT HOT BODY MARIAH !
Victoria and Naomi looks hungry.

MARIAH!!! Naomi’s one is ugly, its too loose and the sleeves look ugly!! And Victoria needs to eat something and SMILE once in a while!! Mariah rocked it!!

Mariah fills it out though…so of course…Mariah wins!!

Britneybitch @ 10/08/2007 at 7:27 pm

Mariah Marih and Mariah she’s gorgeous!!

Christian @ 10/08/2007 at 8:11 pm

Mariah Carey all the way!

MARIAHHHHH!!!!!!

SHE WON! PERIOD!

LMAO! at the Robot …

Mariah wore that best, i like victoria’s too

MARIAH!! ya’ll need to check out her beauty product especially her perfume,,, ‘M’ by Mariah Carey

MARIAH did it best! If Victoria was a little thicker I think it would have looked better because you only tell how sexy the dress is when Mariah’s wearing it. Hot dress either way though :)

MARIAH!!!!! Love the look. Love MC. She rocks it!

Victoria? Are you kidding me!!!
look at the shoes she’s chosen with the dress, how bloody predictable, she has no class whatsoever.

CLEARLY Naomi Campbell pulled it off best.
Victoria looks horrific, I don’t often say this, but she’s FAR too skinny.

mariah carey

mbymariahcarey @ 10/09/2007 at 2:46 am

the dress is great on both mariah and victoria, but i think mariah should stop doing this hands on hips sort of a pose cuz it really makes her shoulders look wide

Mariah, definitely.

Mariah of course!

Mariah! She looks amazing!

Sovin from Cambodia @ 10/09/2007 at 11:10 am

Definitely Mariah. She’s too hot.

i just wanna say they all look gd.Mariah is always given a hard time.For a womna of her age her bodys bangin..victorias cool 2 bt a difernt frame all together.Mariahs gt curves the other 2 dnt.Bt they all look gd.;)

Meu cú no varal e minha neca também…

Mariah é Mariah e ponto !!!

MARIAH—Definetly wore it best-she always looks the best!!!

mariah’s hotter AND OLDER than both them anorexic hoes

MARIAH CAREY of course…

Um, for those calling Naomi ugly, I dare you to have the type of body this woman has! She is eternally skinny, and wonderfully muscular at the same time. I love Mariah, but she is definitely not slim, which an Alia dress calls for. And just so y’all know Naomi Campbell is Azzedine Alia’s muse! He designs dresses with Naomi in mind. So, as far as the designer is concerned, Naomi looks best in his creations. So, none of your teenage, ill-informed, badly-spelled opinions matter.

I think Posh is very classy, and I love that she has a hard-edge sense of style. Naomi Campbell is the best looking female model ever! Try that on for size, you fat cows!

i personally dont like the dress at all, i think it is one of those dress that are not that easy to wear, it takes a lil bit of extra something to make that dress look cool. actually im a fan of all 3 ladies, but i dont think the dress complimented naomi at all, the color is way out and then her hair is hedious, the boots rocks of course, but all in all its thumbs down. Mariah on the end, everybody knows she is a sexy lady with the curves in all the right places but with this dress, it does not show, except of course for the boobs, but in all, it did not flatter her body structure at all. while victoria, made the dress looked like you can actually wear it, as if its just an ordinary kind of dress with class, that’s what made her different and looked way better than naomi and mariah. so for victoria wins this face off…

let me ask you this, with the dress the 3 ladies are wearing, which one will you think will look good on you? if u answer that then you’ll have your winner….:D

MARIAH OF COURSE SHE IS THE ONLY ONE THAT ISNT STICK THIN. MARIAH IS BEAUTIFUL ALWAYS!! GO MIMI!:D

Definitely Mariah FTW! :)

I love mariah,but… i have to go with VB, she can wear nefink and look gd,disagree if u want but she wudnt b one of the biggest fashion icons in the world if she luked a tramp all the time. As 4 Naomi sort yaself out love, your a “model”….for fuksake!

MARIAH MOTHA ****** CAREY YOU DUM HOES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Mariah looks better of the three ladies. Victoria comes pretty close in second. I don’t like her all around brownish color. It’s like everythings in one color.

Mariah Carey

victoria
she looks gorgeous

MIMI WIN DEFINETLY…!I DONT LIKE NAOMI AND VICTORIA BOTH GIRLS DONT HAVE A FIGURE…!I LUV MIMI AND FOR ME MIMI WINS…TRYING HARD FOR NAOMI AND VICTORIA…SO BETTER LUCK NXT TIME..!

It would be Mariah Carey. Far more better than Victoria and Naomi.

MARIAH CAREY OF COURSE !!! She’s so beautiful in this dress !!!

Mariah of course
She is so beautiful

shut up!! definitely MARIAH CAREY!!
she’s got a better body than those two!
victoria is a ******* stick!
sure shes fashionable, but not soxy, only skinny!

Naomi and Victoria. I don’t like Naomi’s haircut but dress looks pretty on her.

Comment and Share!








You have of 5,000 characters left.