Gerard Butler @ Waverly Inn

Scottish hunk Gerard Butler and a female friend catch dinner at Vanity Fair supremo Graydon Carter’s restaurant Waverly Inn in NYC’s West Village Thursday night.

Gerard’s romantic comedy P.S. I Love You costarring Hilary Swank opens in theaters nationwide today! Sadly, it was received a paltry 15% from RottenTomatoes with critics calling the movie a “romantic cliche,” having an “uninspired romantic formula” and simply put, “blithely inept.”

Sounds like you should skip this one and save your money. Go see Juno if you haven’t already!

Also spotted at the Waverly Inn on Thursday: musician John Mayer and actor Emile Hirsch (Into the Wild)