Man.. David A. was cute in the beggining.. but in the second I saw he forgot his lyrics in the performace, I realized he is TOO young to win this.. he doesn’t have the maturity to be an idol, and that’s it..

And I don’t say this just because the forgotten lyrics… many other things proove that he’s just a child, that you crack under pressure…

It’s like simon said once, with that thing “vote for talent instead of popularity”

why ramielle?!
she’s better than kristy!

No Way……………ramiele is good!!!!!!… it should be kristy lee cook! Really Sad to see her go.

it should’ve been KRISTY!!!!!!!!!!! and mama brooke is part of bottom 3??? oh c’mon!

KRISTY SHOULD LEAVE.
OMG.
RAMIELE IS THE BEST.
SHE SHOULD STAY.
STAY.
REALLY.
I’m so sad. : (

>>Hi IdolFan

I really like your comments. Yo are on top and very well thought. I really enjoyed reading your comments.

I do not agree with everything but I agree with almost everything that you wrote. >>

Thanks, Mary. Glad to see that there’s somewhat of a contingent of like-minded people on here.

I called it yesterday - the only thing I got wrong was Brooke and not Jason Castro being in the bottom 3.

However, when I watched the playbacks Jason sang his song better than Brooke did. Brooke was only in there because of a poor song choice.

Kristy wasn’t going to go home on a “country” themed week. Next week with Mariah Carey she will be gone I’m sure unless she finds a good song choice. But country fans are notoriously loyal and I’m sure that we will see Kristy again no matter when she goes out because she will get a record deal just like Kellie Pickler did. Country fans love blonde hair blue eyed pretty girls with a twang in her voice. She doesn’t sing that bad and they can work wonders for her in the studio I’m sure.

definitely the next ones to go should be though

KRisty - Jason -

Top 4 will be definitely:

Michael Johns
David Archuletta
David Cook

And one of these three girls - Brooke, Carly or Syesha they are all pretty much at the same level with Carly having a slight edge vocally but I don’t know if she will do as well with the audience as the other two.

I think the final three will be the boys…they are just better.

David A is the BEST on the show by far. Even the judges think he is the best. Dolly Parton said he is a great great singer. I don’t know what all the negative people are hearing, but he has such a beautiful tone to his voice. He, in my opinion, is the best on the show. If he does not win it will be a joke.

I’m sad!!!!
Kristy Lee should have gone home.
And Syesha should have been in the bottom three, IMHO.
Brooke shouldn’t have been in the bottom three.

I’ll miss Ramielle
I watch AI because of her
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO…

Really, Mariah songs for next week? Awww I’m sure Ramiele would have excelled in that. Too bad.

she is a good singer!!..

not like kristy lee…

she doesnt act like a kid,
its because the other girls are pretty much taller and they treat her like a little sister..

I hate it.. Ramielle was the only reason I watch the show..
She could sing very very well… although i think she didn’t had a great performance this week.. but still….compared to Kristy she sings better
…if only she step up her performance

She’s good. I cried seeing her go.It seems she is the baby of the group. Well, sad to see her, but who knows,she can do more after that. Her voice is really big, have you listen to her studio version of Alone? very nice.