American Idol 7: Top 8 — CALL NOW!

stop hating.
go support your favorite idol, there is no reason to bash on others.

you may not like david archuleta, but i know plenty out there who do. so just leave him alone.

Jason Castro is wonderful…..I loveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeed it!.
I also liked Kristy Lee Cook perfomance too.

DAVID COOK IS SMOKIN HOT

jason castro was the best of the night! brooke was pretty good too. dont like david archuleta at all, and i dont think that was his best performance at all, he needs to go. hes not as great as he is bragged up to be the other remaining guys are better.

MICHEAL JOHNS has my vote!! he is amazingg and despite what everyone else thinks, i also really like Kristy Lee Cook, maybe thats just because i do like country music a lot, but w/e i think she is amazing, not all her performances are greattt, but all in all she has major potential, i think. at least i wish there was someone out there that thought that too… and i am not really feeling David Archuleta too much, yes he can sing, but he is not unique and original etc. he is a wimpy 17 year old who could pass for 10 years old (sorry but he does look very youngg!) and he looks awkward on stage most of the time when he performs. okay that is my sayyy… Carly Smithson is also greattttt and Syesha too i guess… everyone else, Who cares??!

question what the hell did simon meen in brooke proformance i don’t get good or bad!!!!!!!!!

btw Jason Castro was great i think brooke was going to do that song but he did a good or great

david A. well…… nothing to say :( i did’t like it

Michael Johns: mmmm… i like the end he sound crazy but in a great…

Syesha Mercado: shes good she did good but …don’t hit those hi note more

Kristy Lee Cook: 2 words GO HOME

Carly Smithson: THERES A PART I DID LIKE AT 1:00 THE REST IS OK AND I AGREE WITH SIMON

David Cook: THE BACKUP SINGER WELL I DID LIKE THAT BUT HE SING IT REALLY REALLY WELL LOVE IT (BEST) he look like the one it the killer

my vote will always go for brook but if not i will be for mr. COOK or Jason

btw 2: was that taylor swift !!!!!!! IN David Cook PROFORMANCE

Brooke gets on my nerves with that fake-ass smile and crying of hers, and the whiny way she gets when she doesn’t do well or gets criticism. She started off being unique. But I quickly realized that she really is mediocre, IMO.I thought she butchered Carol King’s song tonight.

Carly and Syesha are much better. I want them in the finals !!

I voted for david a. Ive been fan of his since the beginning. Although im kind of getting bored with all the power ballads. I would like to see him do something a little more upbeat.

im also a fan of Brooke, David C, Jason, and Michael johns. Its hard to pick just one. They are all so talented

i don’t understand all this hype with david cook. i mean he can sing but to call him original would be going too far. those rock versions of songs that he did weren’t his - they were by other bands/ artists. in short, all the compliments he’s been getting for being original and all that, well, he didn’t really deserve them.

that’s just my opinion. maybe he’ll actually start interpreting songs in the weeks to come instead of just delivering someone else’s version, i don’t know. until then, i won’t be calling him the next american idol yet.

I meant the girls aren’t good this season

it should come down to a guy and a guy for the final 2
thats it…Im done =)

DAVID COOK!!!!

ARE U STUPID
DAVID ARCHLETA IS THE BETTER SINGER IN THE COMPETITION
WHAT´S WRONG WITH U?
AND SAYSHA AND BROKE TOO
ARCHULETA!
ARCHULETA!
ARCHULETA!
ARCHULETA!
ARCHULETA!
ARCHULETA!

Both Davids butchered their songs… especially David C… I’ve been an OLP fan since I was like 12 and when I heard he was doing that song I got super excited… until he opened his mouth… David A *shudders* another teen age favorite toast… even Jessica Simpson did a better job… although Robbie Williams did it best…

I think ALL the girls did well tonight but Carly was my favorite. I’ll admit the end of her performance wasn’t as intense but I can see her growing into the preformance thing…