NOOOO
she was the best one of the guys should have went home
Brooke was the only real one she showed people that she makes mistakes too and she is a really great singer

America got it wrong! i really liked her. i want David Cook and Syeshia gone. first, David C, then Syeshia, then Jason….and i want David Archuleta to win. he’s my favorite.
anyways, so sad that Brooke went home.

David C suck. he’s next.

ok, so she may not be the best voice, and she has screwed up on that show, but it’s not like her voice is horrible either. she’s very real, and was so sweet, and her earlier performances were so good.
syesha is a great vocalist (fantastic voice!!), but the reason she keeps ending up in the bottom is b/c of bad song choice.

i’m rooting for david cook!!

OMG I am sooo sad se left she was my favourite along with the davids. I cant blieve syesha is still there. She shud of gone.

I think it’s sad that Syesha is in the bottom 2 again like i said before the show is not about talent it’s about popularity

THANK GOD BROOKE WHITE IS GONE!

both davids are in, and so is jason, so for me, there’s nothing to worry about <3 i love the davids!! lol

like i said American idol is no longer about talent Syesha and David C should be in the finale but of course americans surpassed the talent of syesha because people dont know what’s real talent

GO COOK ! THE BEST !!!!!

i so believe brooke white should have been gone way earlier. earlier than carly even. she stumbled way too many times. unlike syesha who is consistent and make rare mistakes. brooke stumbled on words. started to early. forgot her lyrics. she had too many mishaps to stay on.
next should be john castro. he is phathetic

Brooke, we’ll miss you so much. Youre definitely going to find success after this. Keep you’re head high!

I get my Tues and Wed nights back!

finally
syesha needs to leave next and just go to broadway
becase that’s really where she belongs

david cook should win, but jason castro is my favorite <3

david archuleta is so ******* boring. if he wins i’ll kill myself.

Guess it was her time…
Oh I kinda feel bad for Syesha, must be hard being bottom 2 so many times, it must get to her in some way..
anyways, the Davids for finals and Cook ftw!

america seriously needs to stop voting based on stupid crap like looks. do they not realize that the best performers are david cook, syesha, and brooke?

david archuleta is just like the fourth jonas brother and not to mention he is extremely uncomfortable when it comes to having a conversation with anyone. all he sings is ballads anyway. he needs time to grow and mature still. jason castro… don’t even get me started on him. he doesn’t want to win, doesn’t deserve to win, and if he does, it proves that good for nothing talentless guys who are semi-attractive to preteens and young teenagers can win a so-called talent competition when their “talent” doesn’t measure up to the competition at all. and all of you who say jason is the only one with personality, are you ******* kidding me? david cook, syesha, and brooke all have FANTASTIC, unique, and likable personalities.

if david cook and syesha aren’t the final two (which they probably won’t be because people are idiotic), then that just proves that america cares more about “looks” then people who actually bring something more to the table.