Syesha has the best vocals out of all the contestants. It’s really sad that it’s about popularity and not talent. David A. will probably win and it will make the 3rd year in a row that the winners will end up with horrible album sales. If the voters keep it up AI will no longer be looked at as a vehicle that launches careers it wil be the vehicle that kills it. AI is in it’s final years!!!!!!!!!!!

and i agree. its never a talent contest. its a popularity. or should i say unpopularity contest. u vote cos she looks nice. looks pale. nvm!

# 18 - I agree.

Yeah !! Finally !! She’s gone !! Yippie !! Horray !! I’m doing cartwheels !!
Ding-Dong, the Witch is dead, and all that . . .

Brooke should’ve left a long time ago — especially after last week’s start over debacle. The girl is unhinged, unprofessional, and as it turned out, mediocre.

Did you all actuall see and hear Brooke’s performances last night? She was terrible ! Didn’t sing a note on key on any of the songs. And to add insult to injury, she looked like a deer caught in he headlights !
So in my opinion, finally, America got it right.

I don’t, however, think American Idol fans will keep doing the right thing though, as they prove to be a fickle bunch week after week. But I’m happy to at least see one of the best singers in the Final Four this season. You go, Syesha !!!

If there’s any justice though, Syesha will be in the final two. David A is just there because of the teenybopper fans, not because of his talent, looks, or stage presence. He’s mediocre and karaoke, while Syesha and David C are the best in vocals and stage presence.

As much as I like Jason, he or David A. should be next to go — if it’s based on performance and talent — and not some damned unfair popularity contest !!!

I really hate Jason Castro He cant sing! people any like him for his looks!
so ughhh!
he wont win Idol thats for sure

How dare you say that, Kim. Shame on you.

#1… Jason Castro has to go. He messed up both songs even the judges say so… The only reason he is still here is because of his fan-girls. Is this a talent competition or what.
#2… David A.. he was cool at first and i loved his Imagine but now he is just boring his voice is amazing but now that ive heard it soo many times its bland.
#3 David Cook has great vocals and talent. He should only change his hair. At the moment he is the best.
#4… Syesha she does not deserve to be in the bottom 2. She is a fun-loving vocalist. A really likeable person.
#5… Brooke… although she is gone she has a great personality. Her voice isn’t the best but Castro deserved to leave before her.

i agree with lena. whoever “kim” is on the first page of posts: careful, your lack of pedigree and brain cells are showing. you must have a depressingly horrible life to hate syesha for no sensible reason at all. you’re one of the reasons the rest of the world hates america. you give your country a very bad reputation.

THANK GOD SHE IS GONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! HALLELUJAH HALLELUJAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! PRAISE THE LORD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WOOT WOOT.

THANK GOODNESS!!!

Of course it is a little late but she is finally gone!!

it’s not reason enough to hate syesha because she’s in the bottom two. that doesn’t make any sense! it just means not enough people are voting for her, for whatever reason.

if you’re gonna hate on syesha singularly because she’s in the bottom two, that just means you’re a mindless drone following the rest of the herd. it

domo, it’s not reason enough to hate syesha because she’s in the bottom two. that doesn’t make any sense! it just means not enough people are voting for her, for whatever reason.

if you’re gonna hate on syesha singularly because she’s in the bottom two, that just means you’re a mindless drone following the rest of the herd. it just means you wait for the rest of america to tell you how to think or what to feel.

if anything, her being in the bottom 2 consistently has become a self-fulfilling prophecy. it’s like the viewing public expects her to be there. even though she has done well in the past, particularly last week, broadway week, when she was in the bottom 2 with carly.

if anything, i’m proud of her for holding on. you can’t JUST hate someone based on how the viewing public votes.

if anything, the public is the one responsible for making her be in the bottom two BUT making her hold on as well.

your logic just, well, isn’t logic.

I knew this was going to happen :(
I really wanted Syesha gone though, she’s overstayed her welcome on idol