OlderTue, 25 November 2008 at 8:30 pm
Fashion Faceoff: Jenny Packham Dress
Leona Lewis performed her hit song “Better In Time” and then posed in the press room wearing a black sequined cocktail dress at the 2008 American Music Awards in Los Angeles on Sunday.
Earlier this month, Ashley Tisdale wore the same sparkly Packham dress during the premiere of High School Musical 3: Senior Year at the Village Jam Factory in Melbourne, Australia.
Who wore it best — LEONA LEWIS or ASHLEY TISDALE?
Share This Post:
Credit: RCFA; Photos: Frederick M. Brown/Vince Bucci/Lucas Dawson/Getty
Posted to: Ashley Tisdale, Fashion Faceoff, Leona Lewis
Related posts:
Posted to: Ashley Tisdale, Fashion Faceoff, Leona Lewis
Related posts:
183 Comments
ashley looks so much better!!!!!
ashley!
hate the dresss…ashley tho
that dress look ugly period!!!
Ashley wore it the best.
love ash
love ash
ashleyyyyyyyyy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ashley
Leona Lewis for sure, she has the body for it and she fills it out more unlike Ashley who’s a complete stick.
assshhley
Ashley wins
ashley for su-re!
i abolutely love ashley but i think the dress looks better on Leona cuz she fills the dress out
Ashley!
leona lewis wore it wayyyyyy better!! it actually fits her unlike on ashley its like baggy and weirddd! and it looks cute with the tights
leona lewis! ashley does not have boobs, and it looks to baggy on her.
leona!!!!!
leona obviosly….ashley have short legs
Taylor Swift wore this dress in gold to the VMA’s. I like it best on her!
ASHLEYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
ashley for the win!
JJ, it should be “Who wore it BETTER,” not “Who wore it best”
leona lewis. def.
of course Ashley
she looks gorgeous!!!
and she is the best!
Ash rocks! lol
vashley fan xd =]
ashley
Leona, she actually has a body too fill it out vs. ashley and her no boobs
Are you kidding me? It’s obviously Leona! Her body fills it out, on Ashley the dress just looks weird. The lines on the dress just makes her body look like a square.
Leona
Normal body, sweet, real vocal talent compared to a fake nose, no chest, squeaky failure of an attempt at a singer. No contest there.
Although it should be noted that the dress on it’s own is pretty hideous anyway, despite whoever it’s on.
i love ashley but on a serious fashion view leonna.
ashley doesnt have the right body for the dress.
Ashley wins the day on this one.
Leona for sure. One person sat there and made all those post. Look at the time on each post.
That makes this voting rubbish.
This is ridiculous. The dress don’t even fit Ashley. It’s hanging off her like it was brought for some one else.
Has to be Leona. I love Ashley but the dress looks like a potato sack on her. Albeit a sequinned potato sack.
Ashley’s look better on my bed room floor the next morning.
Ashley. Without a doubt
ASHLEY TISDALE FOR SURE!!!!
ash looks amazing and she is sooo beautiful!!!!
wait ash always wears everything the best!!
TEAM TIZZY ALL THE WAY!!
LEONA LEWIS ALL THE WAY
Ashley could kiss my ass
LEONA LEWIS!!!!!!!
LEONA LEWIS!
AASSSHHHHLLLEEYYYY!!!
NO COMPETITION THERE!
Ash.
Leona
ASHLEY ASHLEY ASHLEY. Leona’s legs look really fat and she looks way to covered up. Love her music though
leona for sure she feels it out more. on ashley it looked as though the dress swallowed her up so offense ash. but leona kilt it ( that’s slang for she rocked it the best)
Leona, girls need curves!!!!
It just hangs on that skinny little toothpick
the two are beatiful,but Leona fills it much better,
But seriusly people,why are some of you saying if fake nose and real vocal talent and bla bla….This is who wears the dress better remember?no who is better of the two.
Some people don’t have life and try to fill it trying to star fight,how pathetic
The dress looks a little to big for ashlee. she has no boobs no offence but leona has the right body shape and it fits her better so id say leona wears It better!
ASHLEY
OF COURSE!
Hate the dress but ASHLEY!
ashley!!
ASHLEY WORE IT B33ST! SO WHAT IF ASHLEY DIDNT FIT IN IT! SHE STILL LOOKS GORGEOUS!!! GO ASHLEY!
i LOVE ashley but leona wore it better, no doubt.
leona, i think it kind of hangs too loosely off ashley
How about… Neither!
Got to say it’s leona for me!
Ashley fans are obviously going to say Ashley, but let’s all be honest….Leona DEFINITELY wore the dress better. Ashley doesn’t have the body to fill it out well. Anyone (who isn’t biased) will say Leona.
ASHLEY
not huge fan of the dress
they both look good though
but i think leona wore it better :)
ASHLEY!!!!
I don’t care for either of the two girls.
But Leona Lewis wore it better for sure!
she got that body that’d i loved to hit at Yum.
Hate the Dress.
But Leona shes hott and has the body for it.
It just falls off of ashley shes FLAT!
leona lewis!
leona obviosuly fits into the dress better,
but with the black dress on black tights
dont look as great as the way ashley wore
it -simple.
I like Ashley but Leona wore it better.
Both looked lovely…
ASHLEYYYY
ashley, yaa diggg.
Leona Lewis
Leona Lewis
ashley!
Ashley of course
LEONA YA’LL STUPID DUMB F*CKERS
GET YOU EYES CHECKED IF YOU SAID THE CHICK WITH THE MICHEAL JACKSON NOSE
They both pull off the dress in different ways
Put for me, Leona looks better because she has curves and it fits her perfectly
Ashley, it’s baggy and doesn’t fit to suit her figure, but she still looks gorgeous
I’m going to have to say that Leona wore it better. I love Ashley though.
Ashley, most defiantly.
leonna. pairing it with stockings makes it look so much mroe chic.
LEONA LEWIS IS SOOO MUCH BETTER WORRING IT !!!!!!!!!.
Leona fills out the dress better but I hate the tights with it, though. The sandals Ashley wears completes the overall look better, i think.
So I guess Leona looks better?
LL
OI ASHLEY HATERS SHUT THE THE **** UPP U CN ALL DIE TBH UR NOTHING BUT PATHETIC LOSERS WHO CN **** MICHEAL JACKSON
ASHLEY WEARS IT BETTER WHO CARES IF SHES SKINNY LEONA LOOKS WEIRD WITH THE DRESSS ON
Easily Ashley, although Leona does look better than she usually does here, sometimes her fashion choices are a bit off.
Leona Lewis looks so much better as it works with her figure. With Ashley Tisdale its flat. Anastasia wore it as well on a Diva’s show in the UK, seems to be a popular dress.
It looks better on Leona. Ashley looks frumpy in this dress.
ASHLEY !
Uhrm, I’m not a big fan of any of them, but they both look glamorous, like they’re supposed to when they attend functions with the press.
But I think that Leona wore the dress better, even though I think she could lose the stockings/tights. Maybe in a couple of years when Ashley stops growing, she’ll fit into the dress better.
While I’m not a fan of either of the girls, I mildly like them as I think they are both decent girls.
They both wore the dress well but I think Leona wore it better because she fills it out more and I prefer the shorter length.
it looks better on ashley. the black leggings.. no…
ashley, yes
AASHLEY! :)
Leona! ash needs a small size!!!
Ashley of course, leona is fugly
ashley for sure!!
ashley of course!!!!!
i love ashley!!!
It looks sooo much better on Ashley!!
Leona has the body to wear that dress ! She looks great !
ASHLEY!
It looks better on Leona. She fills it out better. Ashley is like a stick here, not her best look.
though the dress is not that nice but i choose ash….
Ashley the BEST!!!
Ash looks beautiful <333
But Leona is very pretty with the dress, too.
I prefer Ash.
Leona looks fantastic…
Stop Hating… “Better In Time”
Leona! for sure
llloooovvvee…………….ASHLEY!!!:)
Leona. Stupid crazy Ashley Tisdale fans, get over yourselves! She never looks good!
!!Ashley for win!!Leona looks strange
Leona Lewis
Ashley!
ashley of course. hate leonas socks and shoes. ashleys skintone is better.
100% Ashley Tisdale….she rocks EVERYTHING!
Kay :]
i this TIZZay wore it better jst because i think leona shouldnt have worn the black tights…
OF COURSE, ASHLEY ! :D
LOVE HER
But Leona is pretty too
You Ashley Tisdale fans are pathetic! The girl has no body shape at all, she is seriously flat! I’ll say it again Leona wore it so much better than Ashley ever will.
Leona Lewis
luv ash but if leona loses the tights it wud luk better on her!!! soz ash!xxxalso anatasia (hope her name is spelt right!) wore it! populor dress ha?!?!
Woww , Ash of course , she is very glamorous , WHO IS LEONA ?
Xooxo.
Of Course Ashley <3
Ashley is the best.
LIZ,KATIE,ASHLEYTFAN and ROUSSE
get the hell over yourselves
i hate it when people result to animosity and snipy bitchy comments over simple engaging questions like the one JJ asked….
your so pathetic, saying leona is fugly, wen you know fully well she isnt, she’s prettier than yu’ll ever be
she isnt strange, is she was strange den why the hell do you’s all listen to her music?
and saying ashleys’ skin tone in better is so fickle, for one why does skintone even matter, and even if you were to consider it … truth be told ashley looks orange.
dont get me wrong i have nothing against ashley infact i really like the girl and fink she looks nice, but i find it immature dat people have to result to calling leona “fugly”, “strange” and den acting like dey dnt know hu she is , cors you know who she is, she crossed those seas and took you by storm so shut the f**k up …
in my opinion they both look nice, however ashleys looks to thin, leona’s posture is all wrong, Ashley looks 30’s suave, while leona is chic, ashley should have put her hair back and leona should have chose different shoes
they look nice in their own way but if i had too chose, it would be leona
.. deres no need for stupid bitchy comments
Leona.
I have yet to see the day when Ashley Tisdale looks good in anything.
ashley, of couse !
You leanna ******* fans are pathetic!!!!!!!!ASHLEY 100% is wwwwwwwaaaaaaaaaaayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy BETTER LOOKIN AND BETTER IN EVERYTHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i love ashley, but i have to say leona
LEONA no contest. stop saying ashley just because she’s on disney you stupid disney obsessed freaks.
The dress looks how it’s supposed to look on Leona. It’s not a tunic and that’s how ashley makes it look.
leona wears it way better!!!!!
What a copy cat this ashley tisdale is!!!!!!!!!!!Ashley Sucks!!!Shes ugly to
Leonaaa Wore It Best =]
ASHLEYYY leona looks like shitttttttt!
Ash .. of course …
ashley look to moch pretty
ashley is beautiful in that dress
Leana is much better I guess…
leonaaaaaaaaaa
leona lewis wore it best,she has a body that actually fits the dress unlike ashley.
people are saying ashely coz she like more popular in the u.s but if u asked in england, most ppl would probs say leona..ash looks fab tho ;) xx
ashley
ashley
ashleyyyyy all the wayyy
Ashleyyy
Ashley of course.
Ashley is always gorgeous!
ashley’s looks way better!!
LEONA LEWIS
leona lewis!!!
NO DOUBT
ASHLEY <3
LEONAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
LEWIS!!!!!!! OFCOURSE…..DUH!
AAAAAAAASSSSSSSSSSHHHHHHHHHHHLLLLLLEEEEEEEEEYYYYYYY!!!!!!!!!!100% heck yeah ashley….:)
LEONA!
i love ashley but on a serious fashion view leonna.
ashley doesnt have the right body for the dress.
LOVE YOU ASH! s2′
ashley absolutly no contest. When i first saw ashley were this in melborne i was in love. she looked absluly fantastic in it. In fact the dress looks so differnt on leona and not in a godo way that i hadnt even noticed she was wearing this dress i feel in lov with on ashley until it was pointed out to me. ashly has the complexion and it fits nicely wit her hair clor. makes it look all the more better. i dont ike teh stockings on leona and yea ashley all the way
LEONA LEWIS!!!!!!
Ashley, absolutely!!!
<3 Tizzy!
leona
Ashley wins of course, she’s much prettier than Leona.
Ashley Looks so much better in it than Leona Lewis, I Think’that the black tights aren’t necessary @ Leona, Cuz she has a dark skin
Ashley
absolutely ashley wear it better than leona…
Ashley is amazing in that dress….
ASHLEY 4EVER!!!!
ashleyyyyyyyyyyy!!
it looks cute on both, but for sure ashley :)
although i dont really like this dress , it looks awesome on both ashley and leona …BUT ASHLEY ROCKS !!!!!!!
XoXoXo!!!!!!
leona’s tights suck !!!!!
DEFINETELY ASHLEY !!!!!!!
ASHLEY 4EVER!!!!
leona’ sucks!!! aaaaaaaaaaaaasssssssshhhhhhhhhlllleeeeeyyyyy!!! :) :)
i thought ashley wore it better….
the tights look weird with this dress … leona didnt pull it offf and
just because leona fills it out doesnt mean it looks better. . . this dress is meant to be baggy and loosly fit. it looks great on ashley!!
ummmmi have to say Leona Lewis!!BUT dont get me wrong or anything i really luv ashley tisdale shes great luv them both!!!
:)
ASHLEY WON!! WWAAYYY OFFFFF!! LEANNA SUCKS!!!!! AAAAASHHLLEEYY! ASHLEY!!ASHLEY!!ASHLEY!! =) =) AASSHHLLEEY ROCKS! 4 EVER………………………………..DDUUHHHH
Ashley :]]
i was at the front of the barrier at the melbourne premier of hsm3
ashley looked AMAZING
i loved the dress
she looks waaaaayyyy better
wth is up with the tights and shoes leona lewis is wearing!??!?!
AAAAAAAAAA……………….dduuhhhhh Ashley! =) she RRR000ockksssss…………..
ashley looks so much nicer!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ashley!
ASHLEY
AAASSSHHHHLLLEEYYY!! wwwaayyy oooffffff she is much better than that fatass dork! leona lewis BBITTCCHHH!!! lolz GGGGGGGOOOOOOO AAAAAAAAASSSSSSHHHHHHHHLLLLLLEEEEEEEYYYYYYY!!!
<3 u! =) :D :)
ASHLEY WORE IT SOOOO MUCH BETTER.
leona looks like an fn man. -.-
ummmmmm, i’m sorry to say this but that dress is UGLY. like seriously, its veryyy ugly. but i bet if vanessa wore it, it’ll make the dress VERY PRETTY!!!!!
ash
ash
Deffiently Leona Lewis.. she was actually ABLE to wear this dress.. unlike Ashley who is a stick right now and that doesn’t in any way suit this dress. So I dont know how any of you can say it suits Ashley better. She just has more “Fans” then Leona, but Leona deffiently looks better.
ashley man ! she won …
ASHLEY.
Ashley! She looks gorgeous! Better than Leona.
ashhhhhhhhhleeey! she rocks, ok
Leona hands down looks better. She has curves, and fills it out. Ashley has no body.
Ash, for sure! Lewis1 thights and her legs are ugly with this dress! Ashley has got nice legs!
ASHLEY is the best!
thanks fanz,love you all, the people who hates me: HATE VANESSA,NOT ME I’M SOOOOOOOOO SPECIAL, I have an ashleymance, what about you guyzz=?
well,contact me
Peace Love & Shopping
Byebye
Ashley Michelle Tizz (LL
Hey guyz, i’m holly madison, from girls next door & girls of the playboy mansion
the ones who love me:
this is my email:
hollybunny@hotmail.com
Kisses (O)
Holly
i think youre all being really mean about her. she so has got a nice figure its just that the dress is big. And ash is NOT a stick
leona , so i better with loads of dresses…
as for ashly… baggy, she is skinny and ever so small boobed lady …lol
leona is so much better, the body is great, her boobs fill out the dress more and it is shorter than ashleys- ashley looks like a boffin… :S
ashley, of couse. ashley is always better!
TISS FOREVER! ♥
ASHLEY TISDALE!!!!
ASHLEY TISDALE!!!!
ashley tisdale!!! of course!!!
Leona is so ugly!!
Comment and Share!
E-mail to a Friend or share on Facebook, Twitter, MySpace and more!