OlderMon, 02 February 2009 at 12:05 pm
Fashion Faceoff: Elizabeth & James Top
Vanessa Hudgens celebrated her birthday in a cute Elizabeth and James “Tokyo” top while out with boyfriend Zac Efron in Los Angeles. The 20-year-old finished off her look with a Chanel mini bag and Christian Louboutin “Marilou Zeppa” wedges.
Jennifer Garner stepped out Saturday (January 31) for a bite to eat in Brentwood, Calif. The 36-year-old actress completed her look with long, stone-wash jeans and flats.
FYI: Elizabeth and James is a contemporary sportswear line from Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen.
Who wore their E&J top best — VANESSA HUDGENS or JENNIFER GARNER?
Share This Post:
107 Comments
Vanessa wore it better.
Vanessa .. The top looks too big for Jen.. since Jen decided to button it
up… Why would Jen buy a top from Mary Kate and Ashley line??
those jeans on Jennifer make her look bottom heavy.
DUH IT’S TOTALLY OBVIOUS THAT vANESSA WORE IT BETTER!!!!!
EVERYTHING LOOKS GOOD ON HER
Vanessa, no doubt about that!
Both look beautiful but my vote goes to Vanessa.
vanessa 100000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000%
vanessa she made it look hot
both. but it looks a way better on venessa.! guess jus because she’s in shape or s.th.
vanessa!!!!!!!!!!
Okay, this sh*t has got to stop. Jennifer stop the madness. You are what they call “J Crew sporty cute”. The hair is sleeker but you need a sleek stylish headband to keep those bangs from DROOPING in your lovely face. You know you can also find a flattering cut of jeans at JCREW since you can afford them and a nice cute white fitted tee.
I don’t know where these stars find all these funky weird crap tops but Garner has the money to look amazing so why does she choose the weirdest cr*p out there? Half the stylists must be on acid because half the crap on her does not look flattering at all.
Im not insulting her but I am saying she can look really sleek even in her downtime with minimal effort if she wants to even if she is a mom. Ben does it and so can you Jen.
vanessa!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
yea vanessa wishes she wore it better jennifer is better screw vanessa
vanessa of course
The key word here is she is not a mom here … she is having lunch alone.. without her kids.. Jen it would help if you altered your jeans..
Instead of having them 2 feet too long… What is with Jen these days
anyway.. always alone.. one time she picks up her daughter.. Vi
asks for her daddy!! and she just mumbles something…and Of course
her friend Penelope was with her.. Jen does need help with her clothing at least she isn’t wearing the K mart cheap sweaters anymore!
It definitely looks better on Vanessa. She more it in a more trendy way and the black skinny jeans went with the top better than with the blue ones.
Of course, Vanessa hudgens
VAnessa wore It Better!
Definitely Vanessa. Maybe a more flattering jeans for Jennifer? *shrug*
Vanessa Hudgens looks way better. I guess jen has just had a baby though.
Love Jen, but Vanessa! :-)
Um this is no contest Vanessa for the win!
Vanessa looks way better!!
vanessa all the way. but i still love u jen.
Vanessa looooks 1000000000 more better then Jennifer
vanessa … duh !
vanessa all the way .. love u bby v .. u rooocksss
vanessa!
V!
Vanessa Hudgens !
VANESSA, OF COURSE !!!!
Vanessa, looks better!!
Vanessa wore the top better. But I like Jennifer Garner more. :)
i don’t like vanessa hudgens at all but i have to say, she wore it best.
Jennifer… x
Vanessa thumbs up!!! she’s got a style sense that’s afmired by so many. It’s upsetting though that JJ & JJJr. would use this picture of Vanessea, there were other great pictures they could have used but, I guess that’s his way of fishing us in!!! Great Job.
Vanessa wore it better.
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
vanessa al the way=)
Vanessa 100%
Obviously Vanessa Hudgens. She looks way hotter. I’d hit.
No one!
I think the blouse is pretty ugly.
I think JJ should include an actual poll thingy so we could see.
VANESSA!:)
definetely vanessa! she always looks so stylish!
Vanessa, hands down.
Rachel Zoe must be embarrassed to admit she’s Jen Garner’s stylist!
Vanessa Of course.
Vanessa is the best. She wore better than jennifer.
vanessa is a *****
Vanessa. Jen Garner looks weird…ben looks miserable. sheesh.
vanessa defff!
no second thought here….VANESSA definitely looks wayyyy better.
I’m with you, Sonia. The blouse is hideous. It makes them both look average. Yuck.
I don’t think the blouse is pretty at all. Its strange i saw Vanessa wear it and thought it looked cute. But seeing Jen wear it…
Yeah Vanessa hands down.
i like both!
they both wear it nicely!
I really like the top btw!
Vanessa!
personally i like it better on Jen
i think it looks too trampy on V
That is an ugly top, where is the sense of FASHION in this world??
http://www.mayflower777.book.fr
it blows my mind how everyone is saying vanessa. she looks totally ****** with it half open like that!
jen all the way!
Vanessa looks way better, its a younger looking top. I love vanesa, she looks great in everything!!!
They both actually wore it well but I’ll go with Vanessa as she made it more trendy and matched it better. Besides, I love Van’s style and the poise with which she carries off outfits.
To be fair, Jennifer looks really good for someone who just had a baby. She hasn’t shed the baby fat but she looks nicely curvy in the jeans, I wish she hemmed it though.
there is no competition!!!
vanessa is just way 2 cute and hot for jennifer
she just totally rocked it
love u vanessa!!!
Finally Jennifer took a bath, she needs to leave the roach killer shoes at home. What’s up with her, she is going it alone, don’t she have a new baby at home….baddddd mother. She wants attention.
Vanessa wore it a 1000000 times better.
Vanessa.
her whole ensemble is put together better.
don’t like the bottom half of the way Jennifer wore it.
vanessa 100000000000000000000000 pecent vanesssssa lovs vanessa
Lollipop, you rock! Money doesn’t buy style….and I should know. Why can’t JG get this right????
As much as I like Jen, it truly pains me to say this, but she always looks so sloppy and this was even way before she got pregnant. She wears jeans that look way too big for her and always has the cuffs rolled up and looks so unkempt. How disappointing because she is truly adorable and has such a nice figure. I don’t have a problem with people being casual but wear clothes that fit and don’t make yourself look like you haven’t showered!
i love vanessa’s jeans with it but she should have worn some kind of camaisole, i mean c’mon, her bra & stomach is showing.
vanessa hudgens!!!!!!!
It is so not fair to compare a woman who just had a baby and an (almost) teenager!!!
Jennifer is definitely a beautiful woman but she really needs to dress to show her body. She used to be so hot when she was on Alias and before she became a mom to Vi and wife to Ben. That crew on Alias really put her on clothes that showed off her body. She is old fashioned (WV style) and very modest about showing off her figure. I would love to dress her. BTW, that top is one I would have left at the store.
VANESSA
VANESSA OF COURSE …SHE LOOKED SO GORGEOUS AND SEXY ALSO IN THAT TOP!! Love Vanessa!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
vanessa!
vanessa!!!
I know I’m looking way into this, but the women are so different.
They both wear it well.
Vanessa is younger and has had no kids. It’s flowy and she can be a bit sexy and expose her stomach.
Jennifer is wearing it because it can hide the belly well. Though I think she looks great for just having a baby! Of course she’s got thicker legs right now! Give her body criticisms a break - she just gave birth!
Kudos to the designer for a top that lots of women can wear!
I couldn’t care less about the top, but Vanessa should DEFINITELY NOT wear pants so I can see that beautiful bush of hers she so proudly displayed before.
DEFINETELY VANESSA !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
XoXO
vanessa;)
duh… VANESSA!
Both look gorgeous but Vanessa wear it better cuz she’s younger!!
It’s definetely better on Vanessa…Jenn is too sporty for this.
VANESSA!! que plagia que es la otraa la odiee -.- encimaa que ness sale mucho mas GODDESS! ♥
vanessa wore better
vanessa by far<3
vanessa by far<3
OF COURSE BABY V. DUHHH. NO DOUBT. SHE’S THE MOST PRETTIEST CELEBS.
vanessa owned it….not jut because we have the same name..but literally she rocked it. Jennifer looks frumpy in it..sry..
how uncool to compare a woman who gave birth a little over a month ago to some teenager (or very close to it) - not cool jared!
love them both but Vanessa
NEITHER .. IT’S FUGLY ANY WAY YOU WEAR IT ..JUST LIKE THE TROLL LINE IT CAME FROM
vanessa by 10000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
times
vanessa by 10000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
times
vanessa by 10000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
times
Vanessa wore it better. And ppl, Jared asked who wore it better… not WHO is better.
V definetly wins this one.
I’m sorry, but I’m going to have to say Vanessa. It would be unfair to compare a woman who just gave birth and a 20 yr old girl, but I mean, come on. Jared put those two pictures up, asked our opinion, and we gave it. I love Vanessa’s :D wooot!
VANESSA!!
definitely Vanessa! I love her style, it’s perfect!
wEl DuH vANeSsA iS tHe OnE tHaT wOrE tHe besT .sHe Has bEtEr StYlE…aNd jEnNifEr LoOk So OlD wItH tHe OuTFiT
vAnESsA iS The oNe!!!!!
nessa forever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
nessa looks great.Jennifer garner looks like a granny wearing a bikini and trying to make it look sexy.
jennifer looks lyk a granny wearing a bikini and trying to make it look sexy!
nessa looks great. jennifer looks lyk a granny trying to wear a bikini and calling it sexy.
Vanessa is looking way better.
VANESSa !!!!!!!!!
jennifer looks bad and Fat !
vanessa !!
jennifer looks bad and FAT !
wo0o0o0oow
Vanessa is amazing in this outfit!!
Comment and Share!
E-mail to a Friend or share on Facebook, Twitter, MySpace and more!