To the left, American Idol 5 runner-up Katharine McPhee rocked out a Tadashi beaded minidress int he June 2007 issue of Vegas magazine.
To the right, teen queen Hilary Duff wore the same minidress (available at Tadashi, The Forum Shops at Caesars) for her Star magazine photo shoot.
Who wore it best — KATHARINE MCPHEE or HILARY DUFF?

























